Converting to a Roth IRA can be one of the smartest moves you make for retirement, but it’s riddled with potential pitfalls that can cost you time, money, and peace of mind. From skyrocketing tax bills to missed opportunities, many investors unknowingly sabotage their Roth conversions. Here are the top 10 common mistakes you are making when converting to a Roth IRA and how to avoid these costly missteps.

1. You Are Converting Too Much at Once

One of the most common—and costly—mistakes people make when converting to a Roth IRA is converting their entire pre-tax account in one fell swoop. While it might seem easier to get it all done at once, doing this can push you into a much higher tax bracket, resulting in an unexpected and significant tax burden.

Why this is a problem: When you convert to a Roth IRA, the amount you convert is treated as taxable income for the year. By converting too much at once, you may find yourself in a higher tax bracket, meaning you’ll owe more in taxes than if you had spread the conversion out over multiple years.

Avoid this mistake: The key to minimizing taxes on a Roth conversion is to use a strategy known as "chunking." This involves breaking up your conversion into smaller amounts over several years. This way, you can stay in a lower tax bracket and minimize the taxes owed on the conversion. Working with a tax professional can help you determine how much you can convert each year without triggering a significant tax increase​.

Subscribe to ONE Retirement and get instant access to your free retirement planning tool!

2. You Are Paying Taxes from Your IRA Funds

A huge mistake people make when converting to a Roth is paying the taxes due on the conversion out of their IRA funds. This may seem like an easy solution to cover the taxes, but it significantly reduces the value of your IRA and the tax-free growth potential of your Roth.

Why this is a problem: The beauty of a Roth IRA is the tax-free growth on your investments. If you dip into your IRA to pay the conversion taxes, you reduce the total amount that can grow tax-free over time. Not only do you lose the benefit of having a larger account balance, but you also miss out on the compound growth that could have boosted your retirement savings.

Avoid this mistake: Whenever possible, pay the taxes on your conversion from outside savings or non-retirement funds. This way, your Roth IRA stays intact and can continue to grow without interruptions, maximizing your long-term gains​.

3. You Are Waiting for a Lower Income Year to Convert

A common misconception is that it’s better to wait until you’re earning less money to complete your Roth conversion. The idea is that with a lower income, you’ll pay fewer taxes on the conversion. While this might work for some, it’s a risky gamble that can delay your ability to enjoy the benefits of tax-free growth in a Roth IRA.

Why this is a problem: By waiting for a lower-income year, you might miss out on years of tax-free growth. Additionally, life circumstances or unexpected increases in income might never allow for that lower-tax year you’re hoping for, and you could find yourself with an even larger traditional IRA to convert later.

Avoid this mistake: Instead of waiting, consider starting your conversion now and using the "chunking" strategy to spread the conversion over multiple years. This allows you to begin benefiting from tax-free growth immediately without delaying your financial progress​.

4. You Are Missing the 5-Year Rule for Withdrawals

One of the great benefits of a Roth IRA is that you can withdraw your contributions tax-free. However, when you convert funds from a traditional IRA to a Roth, those converted funds must stay in the Roth for at least five years before you can take them out without penalties.

Why this is a problem: Withdrawing converted funds too early could subject you to a 10% penalty if you haven’t met the five-year requirement. This is especially problematic for people who convert funds without understanding the full implications of the withdrawal rules.

Avoid this mistake: Plan ahead and make sure you can leave the converted funds in the Roth for at least five years before making any withdrawals. By sticking to this timeline, you’ll avoid penalties and ensure your funds can grow tax-free​.

5. You Are Underestimating the Tax Bill

Many people dive into a Roth conversion without fully understanding how it will impact their tax bill. Since the converted amount is treated as taxable income, it could lead to a significant and unexpected tax liability.

Why this is a problem: If you don’t account for the taxes owed on your conversion, you might find yourself scrambling to cover the bill, which can be a major financial strain. Worse, underestimating your tax burden could result in underpayment penalties and interest charges from the IRS.

Avoid this mistake: Before making a conversion, calculate how much you’ll owe in taxes and plan accordingly. Setting aside funds to pay the taxes on your conversion will prevent a last-minute financial crunch. It’s also helpful to consult with a CPA or tax advisor to ensure you have an accurate picture of what your tax liability will be​.

6. You Are Forgetting About State Taxes

While most people are aware that they’ll owe federal taxes on a Roth conversion, many forget that state income taxes can also apply. Depending on where you live, the state tax bill could significantly increase the overall cost of your conversion.

Why this is a problem: If you live in a state with high income taxes, your Roth conversion could become even more expensive than you originally planned. Not factoring in state taxes can lead to a major shortfall when it’s time to pay your taxes.

Avoid this mistake: Make sure to account for both federal and state taxes when planning your conversion. A tax professional can help you estimate the total tax liability and ensure that you’re financially prepared for the impact​.

7. You Are Missing Opportunities to Convert During Low-Tax Years

Another common mistake is failing to take advantage of low-income years to convert traditional IRA funds to a Roth IRA. Many people overlook opportunities during retirement or periods of low income to make conversions at a lower tax rate.

Why this is a problem: By not converting during these low-tax periods, you miss out on the chance to save thousands in taxes. Once you start taking Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) or drawing Social Security, your taxable income could increase, leaving you with fewer opportunities to convert at a lower cost.

Avoid this mistake: Be proactive and look for years when your income is lower—such as early retirement, before RMDs kick in—to make strategic Roth conversions. This can help you minimize your tax liability and maximize the tax-free benefits of your Roth IRA.

Subscribe to ONE Retirement and get instant access to your free retirement planning tool!

8. You Are Failing to Factor in Estate Planning

Roth IRAs offer unique benefits when it comes to estate planning, but many people overlook this aspect. Because Roth IRAs don’t have Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) during your lifetime, this enables you to pass on more money to your heirs tax-free.

Why this is a problem: If you don’t consider the estate planning benefits of a Roth IRA, you could miss an opportunity to leave a significant tax-free inheritance to your loved ones. Additionally, not naming beneficiaries or keeping your beneficiary designations up-to-date can lead to complications and delays for your heirs.

Avoid this mistake: Work with an estate planning professional to incorporate your Roth IRA into your overall estate plan. Make sure your beneficiary designations are current and that you have a clear strategy for passing on your Roth IRA to heirs in the most tax-efficient way.

9. You Are Waiting Until the Last Minute to Convert

Some people wait until the end of the year to convert their traditional IRA to a Roth, thinking they’ll have time to prepare for the tax implications. However, converting late in the year limits your flexibility and can lead to a rushed decision.

Why this is a problem: If you convert in the final months of the year, your tax bill will be due by the following April. This doesn’t leave much time to plan or save for the taxes owed on the conversion.

Avoid this mistake: Plan your Roth conversion early in the year so that you have ample time to prepare for the tax impact. Meeting with a tax professional early on can help you map out a strategy that minimizes your tax burden while maximizing the benefits of your Roth conversion​.

10. You Are Not Consulting a Professional Before Converting

Roth conversions can be tricky, and going it alone without professional guidance can lead to costly mistakes. From miscalculating taxes to mistiming the conversion, the risks of getting it wrong are high.

Why this is a problem: Without expert advice, you could end up paying more in taxes than necessary or missing out on opportunities to optimize your conversion. Even seemingly simple mistakes can have long-lasting consequences on your financial future.

Avoid this mistake: Always consult a financial advisor or tax professional before making significant Roth conversions. They can help you navigate the complexities of the tax system, time your conversion effectively, and avoid costly missteps​.

Bottom Line

Roth conversions can be an incredibly powerful tool for building tax-free wealth in retirement, but they require careful planning and attention to detail. By avoiding these 10 common mistakes, you can maximize the benefits of your Roth IRA while minimizing the tax burden and ensuring that your financial goals stay on track. Whether you’re considering your first Roth conversion or fine-tuning your strategy, consulting with a professional can help ensure you’re making the right moves for your future.

Subscribe to ONE Retirement and get instant access to your free retirement planning tool!

Reference

Epstein, L. (2024, February 27). 11 mistakes to avoid with your Roth IRA. Investopedia. Retrieved from https://www.investopedia.com/roth-ira-mistakes-5185949

Sorensen, M. (2024, June 27). Avoid the 5 most common Roth IRA conversion mistakes. Directed IRA. Retrieved from https://www.directedira.com/5-common-roth-conversion-mistakes

Boldin Advisors. (n.d.). 15 common Roth conversion and savings mistakes people make. Boldin Advisors. Retrieved from https://www.boldin.com/planner